Wiki related questions |
Wiki related questions |
28 Feb 2013, 7:58
Post
#1
|
|
Group: Members Posts: 1080 Joined: 24 December 2011 Member No.: 8905 Loves guessing games |
Okay so got some questions about the wiki. Could use some opinions/directions on these,
Should all the Fortification add-ons be on the same page like this or do they look too crowded and some of them need separate pages? Fortification Does the Troop Crawler page need an overhaul after the last patch or is it too early for it? Troop Crawler Is it okay to update pages based on the info in this thread? http://forums.swr-productions.com/index.php?showtopic=4439 What would be a suitable name for the category of primary resource gatherers like Osprey, secondary gatherers like Hackers or resource gatherers in general? |
|
|
25 Mar 2013, 18:29
Post
#2
|
|
Guardsman Group: Members Posts: 2077 Joined: 22 October 2012 From: Terra Member No.: 9379 Armageddon is here.............. |
Marauder is more of an SPG rather than a tank.
Golem shouldn't be in the same group with Paladin, since it's much more bulkier and it's usage is very different. The Paladin is much more like an MBT, the lore even said that it is what the Abrams is in RL. Mine should be like this: Light tanks: Hopper, Scorpion, Cheetah. Medium Tank: Crusader, Battlemaster, Leopard, Rhino. Heavy Tanks: Kodiak, Paladin. Super-Heavy Tanks: Sentinel, Overlord, Golem, Manticore. Tank Destroyers: Marauder, Jagdmamut, Sprut. Pandur should be in the IFV list. It isn't as tough as a tank. Miska is a scout unit. BTW, some question regarding exclusive units for the generals in 2.0. The KA-52 Aligator will still be the exclusive heli for Orlov which will make the werewolf gone forever, isn't it? Does Thorn still get the LOSAT humvee? And wouldn't it be too soon to reveal them in the wiki right now? This post has been edited by X1Destroy: 25 Mar 2013, 18:44 -------------------- We Die Standing.
|
|
|
25 Mar 2013, 19:15
Post
#3
|
|
Group: Members Posts: 13 Joined: 16 February 2013 Member No.: 9806 |
Marauder is more of an SPG rather than a tank. Figured that as well, However SPG is a rather small section in ROTR Golem shouldn't be in the same group with Paladin, since it's much more bulkier and it's usage is very different. I would keep them both as heavies, the Golem is just a shade to light to be Super-Heavy and the Paladin has too much armor and PD to really be treated as anything less Yes and no. Their usage is very much the same, acting as damage soaks-- though admittedly in different ways-- and both are amazingly resilient. The Paladin is much more like an MBT, the lore even said that it is what the Abrams is in RL. Maybe it is based off the Abrams, I certainly can't recall. However its armor, Drone repair, and PD laser give it the Resilience of a heavy tank That said I will agree it has is under-gunned for a heavy tank, doing damage more in line with a Medium tank--though bombardment or Search and Destroy alleviate this somewhat Mine should be like this: Light tanks: Hopper, Scorpion, Cheetah. Medium Tank: Crusader, Battlemaster, Leopard, Rhino. Heavy Tanks: Kodiak, Paladin. Super-Heavy Tanks: Sentinel, Overlord, Golem, Manticore. Tank Destroyers: Marauder, Jagdmamut, Sprut. I would still push Golem into top tier Heavy, and since the Fully upgraded the Cheetah(currently scorpion) is on par with most medium tanks and even before upgrades is comparable to a Rhino I would still move it up one tier. I hesitate with the Rhino being a medium, but that probably is right. Its just that without Reactive Armor it seems much lighter when compared to other Russian tanks....Especially since by the time you grab that power it is probably going against halfway upgraded tanks of other factions Tank destroyers is causing me the most issues thought since Sprut is very lightly armored and really is lightly armed too( Medium tank gun), whereas Jagdmamut and marauder are very well armed and armored. May be move Sprut into either light tank or ,if it can still carry infantry, into IFV? Pandur should be in the IFV list. It isn't as tough as a tank. I used the Designation IFV for well armed and armored vehicles that could transport. so Pandur really doesn't quite fit Also use 3-4 Pandurs loaded with either Grenade launchers or Panzerfausts and use them against Hoppers or any of the medium tanks. Its hard to argue that they don't at least somewhat qualify as Light tank with that loadout Miska is a scout unit. Your right. For some reason I thought it transported more than one infantryman This post has been edited by FalseDead: 25 Mar 2013, 19:17 |
|
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 22 June 2024 - 23:09 |